The Best Papa Murphy’s S’mores Pizza Recipe Copycat

Share:

Papa Murphy’s S’mores Pizza Recipe

Our easy s’more pizza recipe is so delicious you don’t want to miss out! You have got to try our copycat Papa Murphy’s S’mores Pizza Recipe for yourself. This recipe is easy to make, and you are rewarded with a delicious dessert pizza that is perfect for any occasion. Check out our step-by-step instructions below on how you can easily make this awesome pizza! 

Papa Murphy's S'mores Pizza Recipe very close

S’Mores Dessert Pizza

There’s nothing quite like a delicious s’more dessert pizza to help you celebrate or remind you of summertime. S’more pizza lets you enjoy the delicious goodness that we all love and appreciate about campfire s’mores with the convenience of preparing it in a pizza form. Plus, this pizza makes an all-around delicious dessert pizza that you just can’t pass up. 

Papa Murphy’s S’more Pizza 

Although our recipe is not an exact duplicate of Papa Murphy’s S’mores Pizza Recipe, it is a very close copycat version of the recipe. We are excited to help you make this delicious copycat version of Papa Murphy’s S’mores Pizza Recipe so that you can enjoy it anytime you have a craving! 

S’mores Pizza (Papa Murphy’s Copy Cat)

The process of making Papa Murphy’s copycat s’more pizza is easy, and you are rewarded with a delicious tasting dessert pizza. This is the perfect way to top off your meal no matter what the time is here. This recipe is a must-try, and just might be your family’s new favorite recipe.

Delicious Papa Murphy’s S Mores Pizza Recipe

If you are a fan of s’mores and pizza, then this is a recipe that you have just got to try for yourself. Let’s turn our attention to what you will need in order to make this delicious copycat pizza. 

Copycat Papa Murphy’s Pizza Dough

To make our copycat recipe for Papa Murphy’s s’more pizza, there are a few basic ingredients you will need in order to make the dough, filling, and toppings to replicate a s’more. Let’s look at a brief overview of what all ingredients you need for each category. 

Papa Murphys Pizza Dough Ingredients

Dough

Yeast. Yeast is the leavening agent used for making bread and pizza dough. For this pizza dough recipe, we recommend using active dry yeast for the best crust results. 

Sugar. To help make the dough of your pizza a little on the sweeter side, we recommend using granulated sugar in the dough. 

Water. Using warm water will help to activate your yeast.

Milk. We recommend using lukewarm milk, or milk that is warm to the touch for this recipe. You can use 2%, or whole milk for best results. 

Salt. We recommend using iodine salt, however kosher, and sea salt works as well. 

Oil. We prefer to use olive oil for this recipe, however, vegetable or canola oil will work as well. 

Flour. For flour, we typically use your basic all-purpose flour, however bread flour may be used as well. Also, if you have allergy needs, you can substitute your flour for the basic gluten-free all-purpose flour of your favorite brand. 

Papa Murphy's S'mores Pizza Recipe close up black background

Filling

Butter. We recommend using salted butter, to help add flavoring, and moisture to your filling. 

Brown sugar. Brown sugar in your filling helps to make it almost molasses-like, in that it is melty and sweet. 

Oats. We typically prefer to use quick oats, however, rolled oats may be used if you desire. 

Peanut butter. Peanut butter is an optional ingredient, but we highly recommend including peanut butter when you are creating the filling. It helps to add the extra sweet and savory combination to this delicious s’more pizza. 

Flour. We recommend using a little bit of all-purpose flour in the filling to help round out the texture. 

Toppings

Mini marshmallows. Marshmallows are a must for this copycat recipe. We recommend using mini marshmallows, as we find they give a better result. However, if desired, you may use full-size marshmallows, but we recommend you cut them up into smaller pieces before adding them on top of your pizza. 

Chocolate chips. Chips are another necessity when adding your toppings to the s’more pizza. We recommend using either dark chocolate or semi-sweet chocolate chips for the best results. 

Chocolate syrup. Chocolate syrup is an optional ingredient. We enjoy adding a drizzle of chocolate syrup on top of the s’more pizza right before serving, to add a bit of artistic flair and help the presentation of the overall pizza.  

How to Make S’mores Pizza:

To make your copycat Papa Murphy’s s’more pizza recipe, we recommend starting off by creating your pizza dough, then rolling it into shape. We would then recommend pre-baking your dough before adding your fillings or topping onto the pizza. 

After your pizza crust has been pre-baked, you can remove it from the oven and add the fillings, then top off the pizza with your mini marshmallows, and chocolate chips sprinkled on top of your pizza. 

We then recommend that you broil the pizza for only a few minutes, on low, watching it carefully until your marshmallows are golden. 

One word of caution with broiling your pizza is that there is always the chance your marshmallows could catch on fire as they do over the campfire. To avoid catching on fire, we recommend using a low broil function, or simply bake your pizza at 400°F for a few minutes. 

Then, once your pizza has been baked so that your marshmallows and chocolate have melted, remove your pizza from the oven, drizzle with chocolate syrup, then serve while warm and enjoy. 

Papa Murphy's S'mores Pizza Recipe slice cut

Papa Murphy’s S’mores Pizza

Making your own version of Papa Murphy’s s’more pizza, it’s a very easy process, and it allows you to enjoy the deliciousness of s’mores no matter what time of year. Plus, some more pizza makes a delicious dessert, to any pizza meal, or really any meal for that matter. Now, let’s turn our attention to the detailed recipe, including the step-by-step instructions on how to make this delicious dessert pizza.

S’mores Dessert Pizza Recipe (Easy S’mores Pizza)

Ingredients

Crust

2 tsp yeast

2 Tbsp sugar

3 Tbsp water, warm

½ cup milk, lukewarm

½ tsp salt

3 Tbsp oil

1 ½ to 2 cups all-purpose flour

Filling

2 Tbsp butter, soft

½ cup oats

½ cup brown sugar

¼ cup peanut butter

¼ cup all-purpose flour

Topping

Mini marshmallows

Chocolate chips

Chocolate sauce

Instructions

Steps

  1. Begin by heating your water and milk until they are lukewarm to the touch. Do you want them to be warm, but not hot. Add the warmed milk and water to your mixing bowl, along with sugar and yeast. Stir to combine, then allow it to sit for 5 to 10 minutes, or until the mixture begins to foam. 
  2. In salt, oil, and flour. Stir to combine. Form into a ball, then coat the outside of the ball in a drizzle of oil. 
  3. If you have enough time, we highly recommend covering the dough with a damp cloth and place it in a warm dry location to allow it to rise until doubled in size.
  4. Roll your dough out onto a lightly flowered surface, until it reaches your desired shape. Transfer the dough to your pizza pan, and pre-bake your pizza crust at 400°F for 8 to 10 minutes or until the top of your dough begins to turn a golden brown. 
  5. Remove your baked pizza crust from the oven and set it aside. In a separate mixing bowl, combine all of your filling ingredients and stir to combine. Poor for filling out onto your pre-baked pizza crust, and smooth to cover. 
  6. Add marshmallow, and chocolate chip toppings on top of the filling, to cover the pizza. 
  7. Preheat your oven to a low broil. When preheated, insert your assembled s’more pizza, for a minute or two, just until your marshmallows begin to turn golden. Be sure to keep a close eye on your pizza, so that it does not burn. Every oven cooks differently, so watch your pizza very carefully.
  8. When your marshmallows have begun to turn golden, remove the pizza from the oven, drizzle with chocolate sauce if desired, then serve while warm and enjoy. 

Nutrition Information 

We have estimated this recipe will make a pizza that can be divided into approximately 10 slices. We have estimated that one slice is equal to one serving. We have then estimated that one serving contains approximately 397 calories. It has also been estimated this recipe contains approximately 17.9 g total fat, 13 mg cholesterol, 195 mg sodium, 52.5 g total carbohydrates, and 7.4 g protein per serving. 

Papa Murphy's S'mores Pizza Recipe close up

S’more Bars

Not only can you make delicious s’more pizza, using our above recipe. You can also use the above recipe concept to make delicious and easy s’more bars. These bars, feature the s’more topping, using crushed graham crackers, chocolate chips that are melted, and marshmallows. These bars are made with a crust, of your favorite sugar cookies. 

Easy S’mores Bars

There is a very easy way you can make some more bars, with a crust of sugar cookies. You can easily pick up a package of premade sugar cookie dough from the store, press it out into the bottom of the 8 x 8 pan, and bake it according to the package instructions. 

After the dough has been pre-baked, top in with the s’more toppings of the filling listed above, including marshmallows, and chocolate chips. Broil in the oven just so that the chocolate melts, and your marshmallows turn golden brown. 

If desired, you can drizzle the top of your bars with chocolate syrup before cutting into bar shapes and serving. This is another fun, and easy way to enjoy some more bars for any occasion. 

Top Asked Questions

What kind of pizza is at Papa Murphy’s?

Papa Murphy’s sells many different kinds of pizza. One of the best dessert pizzas is their s’more pizza. 

What’s the best way to make s’mores bars?

To make s’more bars, we recommend using a crust of sugar cookies, either made from scratch or using premade sugar cookie dough. Then, make the dough in a small pan, add your filling and topping according to the instructions above, and then bake again just long enough to melt your chocolate, and turn your marshmallows a golden brown. 

How long does it take to bake Papa Murphy’s bread?

The entire process of making our copycat Papa Murphy’s pizza takes approximately one hour and 30 minutes from start to finish if you allow time for the dough to rise. However, if you skip the rise time, it can be ready in about 30 minutes. 

How to make s’mores dessert pizza with marshmallows?

The process of making some more dessert pizza with marshmallows is quite simple. Start off with your pizza dough, and then add your filling, and top with mini marshmallows and chocolate chips. Broil for a few moments so that your s’mores can melt and turn a golden brown, then serve while warm and enjoy. It’s really that simple. 

Do you have a Gluten Free option?

Easily make this pizza crust a gluten-free option, simply by substituting the all-purpose flour, with a gluten-free all-purpose flour equivalent. 

Can I Cook two Pizzas at once?

You can cook two pizzas at one time, using a large oven, with two separate racks. We recommend switching the pizzas halfway through baking if cooking two pizzas at one time. 

How long does it take to bake a Papa Murphy’s pizza?

The big time of your pizzas can vary depending upon your specific oven. Typically, it takes between 10 to 20 minutes of total baking time. 

Can Papa Murphy’s pizza be grilled?

Yes, your copycat Papa Murphy’s pizza may be grilled if desired. However, please note that this will change how you are pizza bakes. 

Can Papa Murphy’s pizza be frozen?

Yes, you are a copycat Papa Murphy’s pizza may be frozen if desired. Simply prepare the pizza as instructed above, then allow it to fully cool before transferring to an airtight container, or freezer bag. Seal the pizza with as little as possible before placing it into the freezer. 

Do I leave the baking tray on when I cook my pizza?

We recommend cooking your pizza on a pizza pan, or pizza stone. 

Are your ingredients fresh or frozen?

For best results, we recommend using fresh ingredients instead of frozen ones. 

How long will my pizza keep in the refrigerator?

We recommend keeping your pizza no more than 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. Be sure to store it in the refrigerator in an airtight container. 

What is the best way to reheat my pizza?

If you desire to reheat your pizza, the best option is to reheat it in your oven, or toaster oven. 

Papa Murphy's S'mores Pizza Recipe slice removed

Easy S’more Pizza

If you love s’mores, this easy s’more pizza recipe is the perfect thing for you. S’more pizzas are great for dessert pizzas, for any gathering, no matter if you are enjoying summer or any time of the year. S’more pizzas are delicious desserts for any gathering. 

S’mores Pizza

Our copycat Papa Murphy’s s’more pizza recipe is easy, and you are rewarded with a delicious dessert pizza. This is a delicious recipe that you have got to try out. See for yourself how delicious this dessert pizza is by following these easy step-by-step instructions today!

For more posts like this one, follow us on PinterestFacebookInstagram and YouTube.

If you like this dessert pizza recipe, you’ll love these other tasty desserts too:

Share on Pinterest!

Papa Murphy's S'mores Pizza Recipe pinterest image

You Might Also Like

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating