Greatest All American Pizza


The Greatest All American Pizza, there’s nothing quite like pizza as a favorite comfort food. When I think of great American foods, the top ones that come to mind are pizza, hot dogs, hamburgers and ice cream. There’s nothing that comes close to these, or that makes my mouth water quite the same. 

Top American foods: Pizza, hotdogs, hamburgers, ice cream

Growing up, Friday night was usually pizza night at our house. I always looked forward to having pizza. There was something about it that just made our family feel closer together. It was even better when Friday night pizza was followed by ice cream! 

Sometimes we would order pizza, but most of the time we would make it at home. There were a few different ways we made pizza. Sometimes we would pull out a loaf of frozen bread dough and let it thaw, then use that to make our pizza crust. Other times we would make pizza dough from scratch. 

Make Your Own for a Fraction of the Price

Now as an adult, I find the price gap between ordering pizza and homemade pizza remarkable. You can easily make your own All American Pizza at home for a fraction of the price. Ordering a pizza is going to start at $9.99 for a large pizza and increase in price from there. 

I went to Walmart and priced out the ingredients in the pizza recipe below, just to give you an idea of price in comparison. And for roughly enough to make three large pizzas it is going to cost you $11.64. The cost estimate is based on the bag of flour, many of the ingredients will include leftovers after making three pizzas. Making your own, with as many toppings as you want allows for them to be made for half the price if not less, depending where you shop for groceries. 

$1.00 Yeast

$1.22 Bag Flour 

$0.93 Salt

$2.00 Sugar

$2.52 Olive Oil

$2.77 Mozzarella Cheese


$11.64 Total 

(ingredients found at 

Personally, I love to make pizza at home because I get to put my own twist on it, something that you’d have to pay up-charges for at a restaurant. You might enjoy making your own too! Try adding your own spices, or your own unique pizza toppings. You might also enjoy experimenting with different ways to prepare it. 

Homemade Pizza Creates Family Fun

Another benefit of making pizza at home is it can be a project for the whole family if you want it to be, and the kids will love it! I often divide up the dough into little balls and let everyone make their own pizza. My nieces and nephews think that this is the absolute best thing! They always enjoy making their very own shape and concoction. The kids enjoy loading it up with the toppings of their choosing and eating their own hard work. They always get so proud when their very own pizza comes out of the oven. 

This recipe below for the Greatest All American Pizza is the absolute best! Your taste buds will thank you for indulging in it. This is a simple recipe, with step-by-step instructions. Give it a try and let us know what you think!  

Learn all about the difference between a zucchini and cucumber! Everything you need to know is right here! Click here to find out more! Also, be sure to try this delicious recipe for loaded potato salad! It is perfect for a summer day!

Print Recipe
5 from 2 votes

Greatest All American Pizza

Prep Time30 mins
Cook Time15 mins
Rise Time1 hr
Total Time1 hr 45 mins
Course: dinner, lunch
Cuisine: American
Keyword: pizza


  • 1 14-inch pizza pan OR 2 12-inch pizza pans 
  • Pizza Stone optional
  • Pizza Cutter


  • 1 ¼  tsp active dry yeast
  • ½  tsp sugar
  • ¼  cup warm water (95° to 110°F)
  • 3 ½  cup all-purpose flour 
  • 2 tsp kosher salt
  • ¼ cup olive oil
  • 1 cup room temperature water
  • Mozzarella cheese as desired
  • Olive oil or cooking spray 
  • Pizza sauce

Optional Seasonings:

  • Momma Mia’s Herb Blend
  • Italian Seasoning
  • Basil 
  • Garlic Powder


  • In mixing bowl, add yeast, sugar and ¼ cup warm water. Mix together until yeast is dissolved, then let sit for 5 minutes or until mixture becomes foamy. 
  • After yeast mixture becomes foamy, add in flour, salt, olive oil and room temperature water. Mix together. Start on low speed and slowly move to medium speed. 
    NOTE: Do not mix together until ALL of the ingredients are added in this step. Your dough will not come out right, if you mix earlier. 
  • Mix dough together until a ball of dough forms, about five minutes total. 
  • Shape dough into a ball. Coat a medium sized bowl with olive oil, place the dough ball in coated bowl. 
  • Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and place in warm area until the size doubles, about 1 hour. 
  • Once doubled in size, remove plastic wrap and punch the dough down. Shape it back into a ball. 
  • If you are using the dough later, you can now place it in a container and cover with plastic wrap. You will want to use the dough within 12 hours. Pull dough out and let warm at room temperature 30 minutes before using. 
  • Spray your pan with cooking spray. Stretch the dough out on your baking pan to a 14-inch round pizza shape.
  • Bake crust alone at 400 degrees for 8 minutes or until starts to turn gold.
  • Add your pizza sauce, cheese and toppings. Top with any desired seasonings. 
  • Bake until the crust is golden, and the center is no longer doughy. Bake at 400 degrees for about 10 minutes. Cut pizza into slices and serve. Enjoy! 


Depending how thick you prefer it makes enough for one thicker 14-inch pizza or two fairly thin 12-inch pizzas.

Save It On Pinterest!

All American Pizza Pin

2 thoughts on “Greatest All American Pizza”

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating